How to Choose, Maintain, and Replace Subaru Crosstrek Brake Pads: A Complete Guide for Owners

Your Subaru Crosstrek’s brake pads are the unsung heroes of its safety system—they’re the first line of defense between you and potential collisions, responsible for converting kinetic energy into heat to slow or stop your vehicle. For Crosstrek owners, understanding how brake pads work, when to replace them, and which type to choose isn’t just about maintenance; it’s about protecting yourself, your passengers, and everyone else on the road. Over time, brake pads wear down, and ignoring signs of deterioration can lead to costly damage to brake rotors, reduced stopping power, or even brake failure. This guide will walk you through everything you need to know to keep your Crosstrek’s brakes in top condition, from recognizing wear indicators to selecting the right replacement pads and even tackling basic installation.

Why Brake Pads Matter More Than You Think

Brake pads are the critical link between your foot on the pedal and the actual stopping force. Unlike older drum brakes, most modern Crosstreks (2013–present models) use disc brakes, where the brake pad clamps down on a rotating metal rotor (attached to the wheel) to create friction. This friction slows the wheel, which in turn slows the car.

The importance of brake pads can’t be overstated:

  • Safety: Worn pads reduce friction, increasing stopping distances. In emergency situations, even an extra second or two to stop could mean the difference between avoiding an accident and causing one.
  • Rotor Health: If pads wear all the way down to their metal backing plates, they’ll score or warp the rotor, requiring expensive resurfacing or replacement (rotors typically cost 300 per wheel at a dealership).
  • Driving Comfort: Severely worn pads often cause noise (squealing, grinding), vibration, or a “soft” brake pedal, making driving less predictable and more stressful.

Subaru designs its Crosstrek with reliability in mind, but brake pads are a wear item—no matter how well you drive, they’ll eventually need replacement. The key is to act proactively, not reactively.

How to Tell When Your Subaru Crosstrek Brake Pads Need Replacement

The most reliable way to check brake pad condition is to inspect them visually. Here’s how to do it safely:

  1. Park on a flat, level surface and engage the parking brake. Let the brakes cool completely (hot components can burn you, and residual heat can warp measurements).
  2. Remove the wheel: Use a lug wrench to loosen the lug nuts (don’t remove them fully yet), then jack up the vehicle and secure it on a jack stand. Fully remove the lug nuts and take off the wheel.
  3. Locate the brake caliper: The caliper is the metal bracket that sandwiches the brake pad against the rotor. You’ll see the inner and outer brake pads pressed against the rotor’s surface.
  4. Measure the pad thickness: Use a ruler or caliper tool to measure the friction material (the part that touches the rotor). New pads typically have 8–12mm of friction material. If the material is 3mm or thinner (about the thickness of a nickel), it’s time to replace them. If you see less than 2mm, stop driving immediately—this means the metal backing is close to contacting the rotor.

Other Warning Signs of Worn Brake Pads

Even if you don’t measure, these symptoms often indicate it’s time for new pads:

  • Squealing or scraping noises: Many brake pads have a metal “wear indicator” tab that scrapes against the rotor when the pad is too thin. This high-pitched squeal is a clear alert. A grinding noise, however, usually means metal-on-metal contact—stop driving and have the brakes checked ASAP.
  • Vibration when braking: Warped rotors (caused by overheating from worn pads) can make the steering wheel shake or the brake pedal vibrate when you apply pressure.
  • Longer stopping distances: If you notice it takes more effort to stop your Crosstrek, especially at higher speeds, worn pads are likely the culprit.
  • Brake pedal feels “soft”: Air in the brake lines or worn pads can make the pedal sink lower than usual when pressed.

Keep in mind that driving habits drastically affect pad life. Aggressive braking (hard stops from highway speeds), frequent towing, or driving in hilly/mountainous areas can cut pad life by 30–50%. Conversely, gentle, gradual braking in city traffic may extend it beyond the average 30,000–70,000 mile range. Always check your owner’s manual for Subaru’s specific recommendation—most Crosstrek guides suggest inspecting pads every 10,000–15,000 miles.

Choosing the Right Brake Pads for Your Subaru Crosstrek

Not all brake pads are created equal. The market offers three main types, each with trade-offs in performance, noise, dust, and durability. Here’s what Crosstrek owners need to know:

1. Ceramic Brake Pads

  • Pros: Made from ceramic fibers, clay, and copper, these pads are quiet (no squealing), produce minimal brake dust (a big plus for keeping wheels clean), and dissipate heat well, reducing rotor wear. They’re also low-abrasive, meaning they’re gentler on rotors.
  • Cons: More expensive than other options (typically 150 per set). They can struggle in extreme cold or very wet conditions, as the ceramic material takes longer to heat up and reach optimal friction.
  • Best for: Crosstrek owners prioritizing a smooth, quiet ride and low maintenance (e.g., daily commuters, families).

2. Semi-Metallic Brake Pads

  • Pros: Blends of 30–70% metal (iron, copper, steel) and friction materials, these pads handle heat exceptionally well, making them ideal for high-performance driving or stop-and-go traffic. They’re durable and cost-effective (120 per set).
  • Cons: Noisier than ceramic pads (more prone to squealing), produce more brake dust (which can stain wheels), and are more abrasive to rotors over time.
  • Best for: Crosstrek owners who drive aggressively, tow trailers, or live in areas with steep terrain (e.g., mountain roads).

3. Organic (Non-Asbestos) Brake Pads

  • Pros: Made from natural materials like rubber, glass, or Kevlar, these are the cheapest option (80 per set) and produce very little noise or dust.
  • Cons: They wear out quickly (often lasting just 20,000–40,000 miles), overheat easily, and offer poor performance in wet or cold conditions.
  • Best for: Rarely recommended today—only consider organic pads if you’re on a tight budget and drive very gently (e.g., occasional short trips).

Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) vs. Aftermarket Pads

Subaru’s OEM brake pads (sold through dealerships) are designed specifically for Crosstreks, ensuring perfect fitment and compatibility. They’re a safe choice for most owners, especially if you want peace of mind. However, aftermarket pads from reputable brands like Brembo, EBC, or ACDelco often match or exceed OEM quality at a lower price.

When choosing aftermarket, always verify compatibility with your Crosstrek’s year, trim, and engine size (e.g., 2.0L vs. 2.4L). Check reviews on automotive forums (like SubaruOutback.org) or retailer sites (Amazon, RockAuto) to see if other Crosstrek owners report issues with noise, dust, or fit. Avoid generic “universal fit” pads—they rarely match the precision of OEM or brand-name aftermarket options.

Replacing Subaru Crosstrek Brake Pads: DIY vs. Professional Help

Replacing brake pads is a common DIY project, but it requires care. Here’s a breakdown of both options:

DIY Replacement: Steps and Tools

If you’re handy with tools and comfortable working under a car, replacing pads yourself can save money (labor costs at a shop typically add 200 per axle).

Tools You’ll Need:

  • Jack and jack stands (or a hydraulic lift)
  • Lug wrench (or impact gun)
  • C-clamp or brake piston tool (to retract the caliper piston)
  • Socket set (usually 14mm or 17mm for caliper bolts)
  • New brake pads (ensure they match your Crosstrek’s specs)
  • Brake lubricant (for caliper slides and back of pads—never use WD-40)
  • Wire brush (to clean rust from rotor and caliper slides)

Step-by-Step Process:

  1. Loosen lug nuts: Use the lug wrench to turn them counterclockwise (don’t remove fully yet).
  2. Jack up the vehicle: Place the jack under the Crosstrek’s designated jack point (refer to your owner’s manual—usually near the wheel well) and lift until the tire is 2–3 inches off the ground. Secure with jack stands.
  3. Remove the wheel: Unscrew the lug nuts and take off the wheel.
  4. Remove the caliper: Use a socket to loosen the caliper bolts (usually two, located at the top and bottom of the caliper bracket). Gently slide the caliper off the rotor—do not let it hang by the brake hose (use a bungee cord to hang it from the suspension to avoid damaging the hose).
  5. Remove old pads: Slide the old pads out of the caliper bracket. Inspect the bracket for rust or debris—clean it with a wire brush if needed.
  6. Retract the caliper piston: Use a C-clamp to compress the piston back into its bore (this creates space for the thicker new pads). Apply brake lubricant to the piston face to prevent seizing.
  7. Install new pads: Insert the inner pad first (it may have a metal tab that aligns with the caliper bracket), then the outer pad. Apply lubricant to the back of both pads (where they contact the caliper bracket) to reduce noise.
  8. Reinstall the caliper: Slide the caliper back over the rotor, aligning it with the bracket. Tighten the caliper bolts to the manufacturer’s torque specification (usually 25–30 ft-lbs—check your manual).
  9. Reinstall the wheel: Put the wheel back on, hand-tighten the lug nuts, then lower the vehicle to the ground. Tighten the lug nuts in a star pattern to 80–100 ft-lbs.
  10. Bed in the brakes: To ensure proper seating of the new pads and rotors, drive gently for the first 50–100 miles. Avoid hard braking during this period—gradually increase stopping force over several stops.

Important Notes for DIYers:

  • Always replace brake pads in pairs (both front wheels, or both rear wheels) to ensure even braking.
  • If your Crosstrek has rear brake pads with electronic parking brakes (common in 2019+ models), you’ll need to follow special procedures to retract the parking brake mechanism—consult a service manual or video tutorial.
  • If you’re unsure about any step (e.g., caliper piston removal, torque specs), stop and take your Crosstrek to a professional.

Professional Replacement: When to Call a Shop

Even if you’re capable of DIY, there are scenarios where professional service is safer:

  • Rear brakes with electronic parking brakes: These require specialized tools to reset the parking brake after pad replacement.
  • Worn rotors: If your rotors are scored, warped, or below the minimum thickness (check your manual), they need resurfacing or replacement. A shop can machine rotors on-site or recommend new ones.
  • Noise or vibration issues: If new pads still squeal or vibrate, a professional can check for hidden problems (e.g., warped rotors, caliper misalignment).
  • Time constraints: If you don’t have the time or workspace to do the job properly, a certified technician (ASE-certified, preferably with Subaru experience) can ensure the job is done right the first time.

Most auto parts stores (AutoZone, O’Reilly) offer free brake inspections—if they find worn pads, they can often recommend a trusted local shop for replacement.

Maintaining Your Subaru Crosstrek Brake Pads for Longevity

Proper maintenance can extend the life of your brake pads and save you money. Here are actionable tips:

  • Avoid aggressive braking: Hard stops from high speeds generate more heat and wear. Instead, brake gradually and early when possible.
  • Clean your brakes: Every 10,000–15,000 miles, apply a brake system cleaner to the rotors and calipers to remove dirt, grease, and brake dust (these can accelerate wear).
  • Check brake fluid: While not directly related to pads, old or contaminated brake fluid can affect braking performance. Flush it every 2–3 years (refer to your manual for the exact interval).
  • Inspect after long trips or heavy use: If you’ve towed a trailer, driven in mountainous areas, or hauled heavy cargo, have your brakes checked afterward—extra weight increases stopping force and pad wear.
  • Address issues early: If you notice squealing, vibration, or longer stopping distances, don’t wait. Early intervention prevents more costly damage to rotors or calipers.

Final Thoughts: Your Safety Depends on It

Brake pads are one of the most critical components of your Subaru Crosstrek—they’re not an expense to cut corners on. By understanding when to replace them, choosing the right type for your driving habits, and maintaining them properly, you’ll ensure your Crosstrek stops reliably for years to come. Whether you opt for DIY replacement or trust a professional, prioritize quality parts and precise installation. Remember: the next time you press your brake pedal, you’re relying on those small, unassuming pads to keep you safe. Don’t leave that to chance.

Back to blog